BLOG
Can I Keep the Fee When a Client Doesn't Show Up?
Whether you can keep a no-show fee depends on what the client agreed to and when they paid. What five scheduling tools do, and what US law and research say.
Airtym · October 15, 2026
Read as markdownCan I keep the fee when a client doesn't show up?
Possibly, and the answer is set before the session. On our reading of the sources below, whether you are entitled to the fee depends on a term the client saw and accepted before paying (ideally in writing) and an amount close to what a missed session costs you. Whether you can collect it without chasing depends on whether you already hold the money, and even then the client can dispute the charge. This research found no US statute, appeals-court decision or regulator action on a coach's no-show fee, so treat this as general information, not legal advice.
- What Calendly, Acuity, Paperbell, Setmore and SimplyBook.me do when a client doesn't show up
- What the research says about no-show fees, including an older study in which a $30 fine cut no-shows among repeat no-show patients
- How US law treats a fee agreed in advance and an online cancellation term, and where it is unsettled
- Which facts you need on hand when a client disputes a fee
What the software does when a client doesn't show
| Enforces the cancel window | What happens to the money on a no-show | |
|---|---|---|
| Calendly | No. On paid plans it displays the policy; you choose only whether invitees get self-service cancel links | Nothing. Refunds are manual, by the account holder |
| Acuity Scheduling | Yes, through scheduling limits | No automatic charge described. Its help pages describe saving a card and charging it by hand from the appointment. The archived copies restrict that feature to Stripe or Square, and no card is saved when a client books a free appointment |
| Paperbell | Clients can cancel up to 24 hours before, then must contact you | The missed session is used up and no new one is granted automatically; you can add one by hand. Paperbell cannot tell whether a client showed up |
| Setmore | Yes, up to a week's notice | Nothing automatic. Deposits (a Pro plan feature) apply to every service on the booking page and are not refunded automatically |
| SimplyBook.me | Yes, through a free custom feature you enable, with a warning to the client | No automatic charge published. Its pages note that a client may contact their bank for a refund of a deposit, which leaves you little to do (they say such cases should be rare), and say you can allow or prohibit a "Pay later" option for deposits |
Quotes and details come from each company's own pages, read September 29 and rechecked October 12, 2026: Calendly and Stripe, Paperbell on no-shows, Paperbell on rescheduling, Setmore deposits, Setmore cancellation policy (notice settable up to one week), SimplyBook.me deposits and SimplyBook.me cancellation policy. Acuity's pages are cited here as dated Internet Archive copies, which open without a login: Saving card details, archived February 20, 2026, Collecting payments after booking, archived August 13, 2025 and Limiting no-show appointments, archived September 13, 2025. The first says the feature requires "Stripe or Square as your sole payment processor," and that a client whose card was saved through Square gets an email that lets them remove it, which blocks a later charge. The second lists the charge as steps a person takes from the appointment. None of the three archived copies describes a charge that fires on a no-show, and neither do the live pages read October 12, 2026 (Acuity, Collect payment after booking). Acuity may change its pages, so read the live versions before you rely on this row.
Calendly says the policy is text: "Calendly will display your cancellation policy, but it doesn't restrict cancellations or reschedules based on the policy" (Calendly). Paperbell states the limit plainly: "Paperbell does not have a way to automatically recognize whether or not a client showed up for a call" (Paperbell). The documentation describes four levers across the five: take money at booking, limit cancellations by notice period (every tool except Calendly), a required checkbox on Acuity's intake form, so the client acknowledges the policy before finishing the booking, and reminders, which Acuity sends as up to three emails and one text message and which can repeat your cancellation policy (Limiting no-show appointments, archived September 13, 2025). The checkbox is an agreement step, reminders are about attendance, and the other two are about money and timing. Of the five, SimplyBook.me's pages are the only ones that name the risk of a bank dispute after a deposit: some clients "may contact their bank directly to get refund of deposits in which case there is little that can be done but such cases should be rare" (SimplyBook.me).
This is a search of vendor documentation. A charge that fires without a click could exist in a tool or plan these pages do not describe, or in a tool outside these five. Whatever tool you use, turn on payment at booking, a cancellation limit and reminders where it has them, and put the term in the description or payment step the client sees before paying if the tool has no checkbox (our reading).
Do no-show fees even reduce no-shows?
This research turned up one randomized trial of a no-show fine. Appointments at the orthopedic clinic of one Danish regional hospital were randomly assigned to a policy of a 250 Danish kroner fine (about 34 euros) for missing an appointment without canceling first. Of the 3,333 appointments randomized to the fine, 130 (5%) of those not canceled went unattended. Of the 3,413 randomized to no fine, 131 (5%) did (Blaehr, Vaeggemose and Soegaard, BMJ Open, 2018). Of the 130 valid fines issued, only 27 (21%) were paid, and 81 of the unpaid ones stayed unpaid even after two reminder letters. The authors concluded that "at a baseline level of around 5%, fining non-attendance does not seem to further reduce non-attendance."
A second source points the same direction from a different angle. In a Haifa day-care study, a fine on parents who collected children late made lateness rise significantly, and it stayed up after the fine was removed (Gneezy and Rustichini, Journal of Legal Studies, 2000). The fine was NIS 10 per child for a pickup 10 minutes or more late, under 1 percent of the monthly fee of NIS 1,400 (about $380), and the authors call it "relatively small but not insignificant." They suggest that a penalty can change what the people involved understand about the situation, so the effect on behavior may be the opposite of what was expected, and they write that a "large enough" fee would eventually reduce lateness (Gneezy and Rustichini). The study does not show that a fee near the full price would backfire (our reading).
Neither study tests coaching. The trial was one Danish hospital clinic with a 5% baseline, and the day-care study is 26 years old. A 2023 article by Leibner and colleagues describes two mid-1990s studies that point the other way: a $30 fine at a mental health outpatient clinic cut no-shows "from 20.1 to 9.27%" among active patients with more than two previous no-shows, and a second study found a 14% reduction that was not statistically significant. The authors call the research on fines limited and say it "has produced mixed results." They also anticipated that an Israeli proposal letting health plans take a co-payment at booking (co-payments there are under $10) would have "minimal impact on no-show rates," and said meaningful change would take better service availability, easier cancellation or "substantial fines" (Leibner et al., Israel Journal of Health Policy Research, 2023).
A 2023 systematic review of 61 studies, most of them randomized trials, of behavioral-economic ways to get patients to attend outpatient appointments found that almost all (58) tested non-financial interventions. One tested financial penalties (the Danish trial above) and another small rewards, such as $15 gift cards, which were associated with better attendance. Reminders were the most tested tool and the best supported (Werner et al., BMC Health Services Research, 2023). So a fine does not reliably reduce no-shows, and if attendance is the goal, a reminder has the evidence (our reading of the review). Calendly says payment up front helps "reduce no-shows" (Calendly) and Setmore says a deposit lets you "reduce no-shows and last-minute cancellations" (Setmore), but those are vendor statements and this research found no independent test of prepayment for coaching. Prepayment saves you chasing the fee after a missed session, though refunds and bank disputes can still arise (our reading).
Will a court enforce the amount?
A court enforces an amount agreed in advance when the loss was hard to estimate and the amount is a reasonable forecast of it, and refuses it as a penalty when the amount is out of proportion to the loss (Aurora Business Park v. Albert, Iowa 1996). The evidence above does not show that fines deter no-shows reliably, and this rule is a second reason not to set a fee high (our reading).
This research found no US statute, appeals-court decision or regulator action on a no-show fee charged by a coach, tutor or consultant, so what follows is general contract law applied to a case no court has described. It is mostly state law, and the answer can change at a state line. The search covered published opinions on CourtListener, attorney general and FTC press pages, two web searches for licensing-board discipline and news reports of small-claims outcomes. It did not cover Westlaw, Lexis or a 50-state statute survey, and most small-claims outcomes are never published.
A no-show fee is an amount you and the client agree in advance for a missed session. Courts can treat that as a damages clause called liquidated damages (our reading; the Ohio court in Groedel, below, analyzed a cancellation policy that way). The Iowa Supreme Court quotes the Restatement (Second) of Contracts, a standard summary of US contract law, which allows damages to be "liquidated in the agreement but only at an amount that is reasonable in the light of the anticipated or actual loss caused by the breach and the difficulties of proof of loss" (Aurora Business Park v. Albert, Iowa 1996). The three states below word the test their own way, and each asks two questions: was the loss hard to estimate, and is the amount reasonable?
- New York sustains a clause if "the amount liquidated bears a reasonable proportion to the probable loss and the amount of actual loss is incapable or difficult of precise estimation," and treats it as a penalty if "the amount fixed is plainly or grossly disproportionate to the probable loss" (Truck Rent-A-Center v. Puritan Farms 2nd, N.Y. 1977).
- Texas requires that "the harm caused by the breach is incapable or difficult of estimation" and that the amount "is a reasonable forecast of just compensation" (Phillips v. Phillips, Tex. 1991).
- Delaware leaves an agreement alone where "the damages are uncertain and the amount agreed upon is reasonable" and rejects the amount only if it is "unconscionable" (grossly unfair) or "not rationally related to any measure of damages a party might conceivably sustain." The harder the loss is to calculate, the easier it is to show the amount was reasonable (Brazen v. Bell Atlantic, Del. 1997).
None of the four cases above involved a missed appointment. They concern an office and warehouse lease (Aurora), a truck lease (Truck Rent-A-Center), a partnership formed at a divorce (Phillips) and a $550 million merger termination fee between two corporations (Brazen). New York's court adds that the agreement "should be interpreted as of the date of its making and not as of the date of its breach" (Truck Rent-A-Center v. Puritan Farms 2nd), so a court looks at the amount as it stood on the day you wrote the term (our reading).
This research found no decision on whether a missed coaching, tutoring or consulting session counts as hard to estimate. A fee equal to the session price is easy to calculate, which is one argument that the loss is not hard to estimate (our reading). New York's top court allowed an advance agreement on what leased trucks would fetch on re-rental or sale even though the lessor's lost profit "could readily be measured by the amount of the weekly rental fee," because "there was uncertainty as to whether the trucks could be re-rented or sold" (Truck Rent-A-Center v. Puritan Farms 2nd). The argument the other way is that reserved time is hard to resell at short notice. An Ohio appeals court accepted it for a surgeon, who "would lose revenue from potential patients whom he could not accommodate because his time had already been reserved," and upheld a policy under which he kept half of a $3,250 fee on a cancellation 7 to 14 days out and would keep all of it inside one week. The patient had not paid in advance, the policy was in full-size print above her signature, and the court found no coercion, noting she was an attorney (Groedel v. Arsham, Ohio Ct. App. 2007). A surgeon is not a coach, so a coach would have to argue that the same reasoning applies. If it does, the case suggests a fee tied to the session price, stepped up as the date gets closer, and printed where the client signs (our reading).
California treats consumer services differently. Where a client makes a "retail purchase" of services "primarily for the party's personal, family, or household purposes," Civil Code section 1671(c)(1) and (d) make a liquidated-damages clause "void" except that the parties may agree on an amount "which shall be presumed to be the amount of damage sustained by a breach thereof, when, from the nature of the case, it would be impracticable or extremely difficult to fix the actual damage." In any other contract the clause is valid unless the challenger shows it was unreasonable when the contract was made, and another statute that expressly sets the standard takes precedence (Cal. Civ. Code § 1671). The statute does not say whether coaching or tutoring is a retail purchase, and this research found no case on the point, so if you sell either to individuals in California, plan around the stricter rule (our reading).
Did the client agree, and were they told?
On our reading of the cases below, a fee holds up only if the client agreed to the term. Show the cancellation term next to the price and beside the pay button, in type as easy to read as the price; make the button say that paying means agreeing to it; and keep the proof: the term as it appeared on the booking page, when the client agreed, when they paid, when they canceled (or a note made at the time that they did not show), and what you told them before the session. In Groedel, the date of the cancellation call set which fee applied. The patient's only support for an earlier call was what the court called a "self-serving handwritten note," and the only evidence in the record of her call was the surgeon's answering-service statement (Groedel v. Arsham, Ohio Ct. App. 2007).
A policy a tool merely displays, like Calendly's, which "will display your cancellation policy, but it doesn't restrict cancellations or reschedules based on the policy," is not the same as one the client agreed to (Calendly). Calendly's guide puts that policy in the calendar invitation and email confirmation (Calendly), while its Stripe setup has a field for "payment terms and cancellation policy" that the invitee sees "before confirming their payment" (Calendly and Stripe). That field is where the term belongs (our reading). Acuity's intake-form checkbox is the kind of step the cases below describe (our reading).
Three federal appeals decisions applying state contract law to websites and apps show the pattern: online terms were enforced where the user was clearly told of them and clearly agreed, and refused where the notice was a bare link or printed too faintly to notice. The Ninth Circuit found a terms link on every page insufficient because "the proximity or conspicuousness of the hyperlink alone is not enough to give rise to constructive notice," meaning notice the law treats a user as having (Nguyen v. Barnes & Noble, 9th Cir. 2014). Eight years later it refused terms announced in "two lines of text in a tiny gray font" above a large green "continue" button, with the links in the same gray as the rest of the sentence, and held that a click shows assent "only if the user is explicitly advised that the act of clicking will constitute assent to the terms and conditions of an agreement." The court said a line such as "By clicking the Continue >> button, you agree to the Terms & Conditions" would have supplied that warning (Berman v. Freedom Financial, 9th Cir. 2022). The Second Circuit enforced terms in Meyer, where an "uncluttered" sign-up screen said, directly below the registration buttons, that creating an account meant agreeing to the terms, with the terms linked in bright blue (Meyer v. Uber, 2d Cir. 2017). These tests matter when the business cannot show the user actually knew of the term. All three were about whether the user had agreed to settle claims out of court (arbitration), so none tested a fee.
An agreement made online counts. For a transaction "in or affecting interstate or foreign commerce," federal law says "a signature, contract, or other record relating to such transaction may not be denied legal effect, validity, or enforceability solely because it is in electronic form" (E-SIGN Act, 15 U.S.C. § 7001(a)). It does not say when a click or a link shows agreement to a particular term, and this research did not compare state electronic-transactions laws. The cases above supply that test.
Agreement is one test and disclosure is another. The Federal Trade Commission Act declares "unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce" unlawful (15 U.S.C. § 45), and the FTC's deception policy says "Written disclosures or fine print may be insufficient to correct a misleading representation" (FTC Policy Statement on Deception, 1983). Its staff guidance on online disclosures says significant fees a buyer would not expect to pay to buy or use a product belong "on the same page and immediately adjacent to the cost claim," with a link beside the price for details too complex to fit there, before the buyer decides to buy (for example, before clicking 'order now'), and not only in terms of use, and that a click on 'agree' does not by itself make a disclosure clear and conspicuous (FTC, .com Disclosures, 2013). Guidance is not a rule: the FTC's 2025 fees rule covers only live-event tickets and short-term lodging (16 CFR Part 464).
Several states now regulate how fees are disclosed. None of the laws or guidance below names a cancellation or no-show fee, so the readings are ours.
- Colorado, since January 1, 2026 (Colorado Department of Law enforcement memo): before a person consents to pay, the seller must "clearly and conspicuously disclose" pricing information "not part of the total price," including "The refundability of the amount charged," what it is charged for and who receives it, and online the disclosure "must be unavoidable" (C.R.S. 6-1-737). A no-show fee is owed only if the client misses a session, so on our reading it falls outside the total price and inside this rule. An exception for services whose price cannot be known in advance may apply, which this research did not assess.
- Massachusetts, since September 2, 2025, for personal, family or household purchases: sellers must disclose "the nature, purpose, and amount" of fees "imposed on the transaction due to the purchase" when the price is first shown and again before the sale, and, for a fee that is "optional to the consumer or waivable by the seller," say so and explain how to avoid it (940 CMR 38.04). The Attorney General says fees that depend on optional consumer behavior after the purchase "are not mandatory and need not be included in the Total Price" and adds that a fee not presented as mandatory can still belong in the Total Price where leaving it out "would be deceptive" (Massachusetts Attorney General). The text does not say whether a no-show fee is imposed "due to the purchase."
- Virginia, California and Minnesota tie the advertised total price to mandatory fees. Virginia's statute, which covers consumer transactions, says that term "includes any additional fee or surcharge that must be paid in order to purchase the good or service being advertised" (Va. Code § 59.1-607). California's attorney general says fees "contingent on certain later conduct by a consumer," such as returning rented equipment late or smoking in a hotel room, "are not mandatory" under a law that does not apply to purchases "for commercial use" or to certain other transactions and industries that other pricing laws already cover (California), and Minnesota's says a fee "reasonably avoidable by consumers" is not "mandatory" (Minnesota). On our reading, a fee that arises only when a client misses a session does not fit that wording on its face, though Virginia's definition says "includes" and Minnesota's statute says "includes but is not limited to" (Minn. Stat. § 325D.44), so neither list is closed. Attorney general statements are guidance that does not bind courts (our reading).
If you sell to individuals in Colorado or Massachusetts, showing the fee, what it is for, who gets it, whether it is refundable and how to avoid it before they pay would cover what both states list (our reading).
Do professional rules change the answer?
Licensed professionals and ICF coaches have more to check. The APA, Texas and ICF rules below all ask you to settle the fee at the start, only Texas requires a signed document (counselors employed by an agency or institution are excepted), and North Carolina's Medicaid guidance bars a missed-appointment fee for Medicaid patients.
- The American Psychological Association's ethics code says psychologists and clients "reach an agreement specifying compensation and billing arrangements" as early as is feasible, and that before using a collection agency or legal measures they must "first inform the person that such measures will be taken and provide that person an opportunity to make prompt payment" (APA Standard 6.04). The APA is revising a draft of a new code (APA Ethics Code Task Force).
- Texas requires a licensed professional counselor to get a signed informed consent or signed written receipt of information that includes "fees and arrangements for payment" before services begin, and to tell the client in writing of any change first. A counselor acting within the scope of employment with an agency or institution need not get the signed consent but must document in writing that the client was informed and consented (22 Tex. Admin. Code § 681.35). Neither the APA code nor the Texas rule mentions missed-appointment fees.
- North Carolina's Medicaid guidance states "Providers may NOT bill Medicaid beneficiaries for missed appointments," citing CMS policy and two CMS letters from 2006 and 1994 (NC Medicaid). The same rule may apply in other states, which this research did not check (our reading).
- The International Coaching Federation's code asks coaches to agree with the client on "financial arrangements" before coaching begins, and says a coaching agreement typically includes "payment terms, cancellation policies" among other details (ICF Code of Ethics). Its ethics guidance calls "a clear refund policy in the written agreement" a best practice and says an agreement should let any party cancel at any time for any reason (ICF, Insights and Considerations for Ethics, 2026). Neither page sets a rule on what a missed session may cost. The code applies to ICF members and credential holders and to ICF staff, volunteers and board members (ICF Code of Ethics), and a coach with no ICF tie is not bound by it (our reading).
If you are licensed, check your board's rule on fees before you set a missed-session fee. If you belong to the ICF, put the cancellation terms in the coaching agreement (our reading).
Where Airtym fits
Airtym's FAQ says clients pay when they book, through Stripe, and that the host, the person who runs the session, keeps the payment if a client doesn't show up (Airtym FAQ). That describes how the product handles the money. Whether the host is entitled to keep it depends on the agreement and the law above. The written term is still yours to write and to put in front of the client before they pay, in any tool (our reading).
Key takeaways
- None of the five tools checked publishes an automatic no-show charge, so your terms and the timing of payment carry the decision. Payment at booking saves you chasing the fee, though refunds and bank disputes can still arise.
- The one randomized trial of a no-show fine this research found showed no drop in no-shows, and 21% of fines were paid. The wider evidence on fines is mixed. This research found none that tests coaching and no independent test showing that payment at booking cuts no-shows.
- In New York, Texas and Delaware, courts ask two things of an amount agreed in advance: was the loss hard to estimate, and is the amount reasonable (California is stricter for consumer services). Keep the fee near what a missed session costs you (our reading). None of those cases involved a missed appointment, and this research found no US appeals-court decision that tests it on a coach, a tutor or a consultant.
- In three federal appeals cases (all arbitration disputes, not fee disputes), online terms were enforced where the user was clearly told of them and clearly agreed, and refused where the notice was a bare link or in faint small type. Put the cancellation term next to the price and beside the pay button, as easy to read as the price (our reading).
- This is general information, not legal advice. Ask a lawyer who knows your state before writing the policy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I keep the fee if a client doesn't show up?
Possibly, if the client agreed to the term before paying and the amount is close to what a missed session costs you. This research found no US court ruling on a coach's no-show fee, and the law is mostly state law, so a lawyer's read of your own terms is worth having.
Do any scheduling tools charge a no-show fee automatically?
Not in the documentation of the five checked: Calendly, Acuity, Paperbell, Setmore and SimplyBook.me. Some take payment at booking, and every tool except Calendly can limit cancellations by notice period. Acuity's pages mention charging a stored card by hand, from the appointment. A feature missing from published pages could still exist elsewhere.
Does a no-show fee reduce no-shows?
Not reliably. The one randomized trial this research found showed 5% of noncanceled appointments unattended with the fine and 5% without it, and only 21% of fines were paid (Blaehr et al., BMJ Open, 2018). A 2023 article calls the evidence mixed (Leibner et al.). The studies concern hospital attendance and late day-care pickups, and none tests coaching.
Does the client have to sign something?
The client has to agree, but a handwritten signature is not required. Federal law says that, for a transaction "in or affecting interstate or foreign commerce," an agreement may not be denied legal effect solely because it is electronic (E-SIGN Act). Courts have enforced online terms where the screen told the user that creating an account meant agreeing (Meyer v. Uber) and refused them where the only notice was a link (Nguyen v. Barnes & Noble) or two lines of tiny gray text that did not say clicking meant agreeing (Berman v. Freedom Financial). A licensed professional counselor in Texas must get a signed informed consent or signed written receipt of information that covers fees, with an exception for counselors employed by an agency or institution (22 Tex. Admin. Code § 681.35). Other professions and states differ.
What should I have ready if a client disputes the fee?
The term they agreed to, when they agreed to it, when they paid, when they canceled (or a note made at the time that they did not show), and what you told them before the session. The term belongs in your written agreement and the rest in your booking record, kept where you can find it when a client disputes the fee.
Related Articles
- Calendly Alternatives for Consultants Who Charge for Their Time (2026): five tools compared with Calendly on price, payment, video and client memory.
- Can Calendly Take Payments? What It Leaves to You (2026): what Calendly's payment setting does and does not handle after a booking.
- Meeting Notes Apps for Client Calls: Two Questions Before You Pick One: how the major notetakers group calls by client, and who does the filing.
- The Calendly alternative with payments built in: Airtym and Calendly, row by row.
Written by
Airtym
Client calls, booked, paid, and on the record.